Problems of Supervisory Communication at Al Azhar primary stage and ways to overcome them "A Field Study on Dakahlia Governorate"

Document Type : Original Article

Author

بکلیة التربیة بنین بالقاهرة – جامعة الأزهر

Abstract

The study was conducted to investigate the problems of supervisory communication at Al Azhar primary stage of Dakahlia Governorate and ways to overcome them according to the viewpoints of both teachers and supervisors. The study adopted the descriptive approach, utilizing two questionnaires as a study tool; the first questionnaire was administered to a sample of (368) primary stage teachers at Dakahlia Governorate. while the other was administered to a sample of (72) supervisors and senior supervisors at the same area. The participants' responses related to problems of supervisory communication at Al Azhar primary stage of Dakahlia Governorate and ways to overcome them were investigated and analyzed. The most important findings were centered around; limited participation of the teachers in the decisions related to developing and organizing curricula, teachers reported a sense of supervisors' discrimination in treatment, lack of financial and moral motivation of the distinguished teachers. These problems scored the highest ranks respectively. Finally, some recommendations were suggested so as to overcome these problems of supervisory communication at Al-Azhar primary stage, thus its effectiveness could be achieved.

Keywords

Main Subjects


 
Dima Muhammad Wasos and Al-Mu'tasim Billah Suleiman Al-Jawarneh (2014): Educational Supervision (What is it - its development - its types - its methods), Dar Al-Khaleej for Publishing and Distribution, Jordan
Ahmed Ibrahim Ahmed et al (2019): The Global Perspective of an Effective Educational Supervisor - Applying to the Kindergarten stage, Journal of Educational Knowledge, Iss. (14), V.(7), Egyptian Association  for the Foundations of Education
Todri Morcos Hanna (2014): Obstacles of Administrative Communication in University Education and the Methods to face, Journal of Specific Education Research, No. (34), Faculty of Specific Education, Mansoura University
Dahman Brini (2018): The Role of Organizational Communication in Achieving Success for the economic Firms, Journal of Law and Humanities, Economic Issue (35), V. (1), Zian Ashour University in Djelfa
Peter Drucker (1997): Management and Work worldwide - in the Art of Management, translated by: Asaad Abu Libdeh, Editor: Joseph El Power, Review: Muhammad Yaghi, Dar Al-Bashir, Amman
Perry Smith (1989 AD): Taking Responsibility - A Practical Guide for Leaders, Translated by: Abdul Qadir Othman, Jordanian Book Center, Amman
Yehia Salem Al-Aqtash (1985 AD): Communication between the Supervisor and the Teacher in the Supervisory Meeting, Journal of Teacher's mission, Iss. (1), V. (26), Ministry of Education, Educational Planning and Research Department, Jordan.
Muhammad Yusef Al-Musaylim (2014): Dimensions of The prevailing communication and their main obstacles among middle school principals , male and female, in the Capital Education Region in the State of Kuwait from the viewpoint of male and female teachers, journal of The Faculty of Education, No. (38), Part (2), Ain Shams University
Hassan Mukhtar Hussein (1991): Developing Technical Guidance in Al-Azhar Institutes in the Terms of Contemporary Global Trends, unpublished Ph.D. Dissertation, Faculty of Education, Al-Azhar University.
Ahmad Juma Ahmad Ibrahim (2003): Educational Competencies Necessary for Arabic language Supervisors in Al-Azhar secondary Stage and the Extent of Their Practices for it - an evaluation study, Journal of the Faculty of Education, No. (117), Al-Azhar University, Cairo
Ashraf Abdel-Tawab Abdel-Majid Hassan (2007): A proposal for a System of Educational Supervision in Pre-university Education in Al-Azhar in Terms of Contemporary Administrative Thought, unpublished Ph.D. Dissertation, Faculty of Education, Al-Azhar University
Muhammad Adel Muhammad Suleiman (2008 AD): A Proposal for Developing Methods of Evaluating Teachers of Al-Azhar Preparatory and Secondary Stage in Terms of the experiences of some countries, unpublished Master Thesis, Faculty of Education, Al-Azhar University
Ahmed Abdel-Fattah Hamdi Al-Hindawi (2013): A Proposal for Accountability System in Al-Azhar Institutes in Terms of Quality Standards, unpublished Master Thesis, Faculty of Education in Cairo, Al-Azhar University
Sherwit Mahmoud Muhammad Abu Awad Joan et al (2018): A Strategic Vision for Developing Al-Azhar Education Management in Terms of Quality and Accreditation Standards, Journal of Reading and Knowledge, Iss.(202), Egyptian Association for Reading and Knowledge, Faculty of Education, Ain Shams University
Ahmed Kamel Abdul-Aziz Anani, et al (2018): A Suggested Model for developing the Performance of members of the supervision committee on communication skills supportive of creativity, Journal of Scientific Research in Education, No. (19), Girls Faculty of Arts, Sciences and Education, Ain Shams University
Iyad Abdel-Jawad , Anisa Attia Qandil (2013): Communication and Educational Communication Skills for Practical Education Supervisors at the Faculty of Education at Al-Aqsa University, Al-Quds Open University Journal for Educational and Psychological Research and Studies, No. (2), V. (1), Al-Quds Open University
Hanan Falah Hassan (2020 AD): Obstacles to Educational Supervision from the Point of View of Supervisors, Journal of Arts, Literature, Humanities and Social Sciences, Iss. (48), Emirates Faculty for Educational Sciences
Hind Nasser Muhammad Al-Majed (2019): The Role of Educational Supervision in Activating the Participation of School Leaders in Implementing the Curriculum from the viewpoint of Female School Leaders and Teachers, Journal of the Faculty of Education, No. (10), Volume (35), Assiut University
Aziza Abdullah Abdul Rahman, Wafaa Mishaan Awad (2016): Effective among educational supervisors for the intermediate stage in Hafar Al-Batin Governorate - field study, Arab studies in education and psychology, a special issue, the Arab Educational Association
Fayez bin Abdullah bin Othman Al-Bakri (1429 AH / 2009 AD): Developing a Supervisory Communication Process among Educational Supervisors and Teachers in General Secondary Schools in the Asir Region - field study, unpublished Master Thesis, Faculty of Education - King Khalid University, Saudi Arabia
Ali Saeed Muhammad Al Haris (2018): The Reality of the Practice of the Educational Supervisor in Improving the Organizational Climate in Public Education Schools in Dammam - field study, Journal of Scientific Research in Education, No. (19), Girls Faculty of Arts, Sciences and Education, Ain Shams University
Abdulaziz Ali Jaafar (2015 AD): a future vision to develop communication and educational communication skills for supervisors of practical education in the Faculty of Basic Education in the State of Kuwait, Educational and Psychological Studies, No. (86), Faculty of Education, Zagazig University
Muhammad Ali Shams Al-Din, Ismail Muhammad Al-Faqi (2007 AD): Administrative Behavior - A Psychosocial Approach to Educational Administration, 1ST Edition, Dar Al-Fikr Publishers and Distributors, Amman (Jordan(
Maysoon Saeed Ghatasheh (2002): The extent to which teachers of the Basic Stage are Satisfied about Supervisory communication methods in schools in Jerash Governorate, unpublished Master Thesis, Faculty of Education, Yarmouk University, Jordan
Fayez bin Abdullah bin Othman Al-Bakri (1429 AH / 2009 AD): Developing a Supervisory Communication Process among Educational Supervisors and Teachers in General Secondary Schools in the Asir Region - field study, unpublished Master Thesis, Faculty of Education - King Khalid University, Saudi Arabia.
Shereen Muhammad Waseem Mahmoud (2014): Requirements for activating administrative communication with university education in Terms of some modern administrative approaches, unpublished Master Thesis, Faculty of Education, Mansoura University
Aziza Bint Abdullah bin Abdul-Rahman, Wafaa Mishaan Awad (2016 AD): Practices of Effective Communication Skills among Educational Supervisors for the intermediate stage in Hafar Al-Batin Governorate - field study, Arab Studies in Education and Psychology, a special issue, the Arab Educational Association.
Fawzi Saad Najm Abdul-Salam (2017): The Role of the Efficiency of the Administrative Communication system in Raising the Level of Job Performance – A Field Study on School Principals in Basic and Secondary Education in Al-Aibar Municipality, Journal of Economic Horizons, Iss. (5), Faculty of Economics and Trade, Al-Marqab University
Muhammad Ibrahim Al-Qaddah (2017 AD): Administrative Communication Processes and their Relationship to Organizational Effectiveness in Educational Directorates in Jordan, Journal of Studies, Educational Sciences, No. (4), Vol. (44), Deanship of Scientific Research, University of Jordan
Wafaa Bint Mohammed bin Ali Al-Zubaidi (2018 AD): Patterns of Communication and its Relationship to Administrative Decision-making for leaders of public education schools in the City of Makkah Al-Mukarramah, Journal of Scientific Research in Education, No. (19), Part (8), Faculty of Girls for Arts, Sciences and Education, Ain Shams University
Saeed Jassim Al-Asadi, Marwan Abdul-Majeed Ibrahim (2003): Educational Supervision, Dar Al-Thaqafa for Publishing and Distribution, Amman, Jordan.
Izabel Pfeiffer, Wahin Wandalab (1997 AD): Educational Supervision on Teachers - A Guide for Improving Teaching - Translated by: Muhammad Eid Dirani, 2nd edition, University of Jordan, Amman, Jordan
Saeeda Chin (2016): Social Perceptions of the Factors Determining the Status of the Teacher in Society, Journal of Humanities and Social Sciences, University of Kasadi Merbah, No. 24, Algeria
Tamani Alsayed Muhammad et al (2016): the Competencies of a General Education Teacher in Terms of Performance Quality Standards from an Islamic Perspective - an analytical study, Journal of Reading and Knowledge, No. (176), Egypt
Hind Nasser Muhammad Al-Majed (2019): The Role of Educational Supervision in Activating the Participation of School Leaders in Implementing the Curriculum from the Viewpoint of Female School Leaders and Teachers, Journal of the Faculty of Education, No. (10), Vol. (35), Assiut University
Radah Al-Khatib et al (1987): Educational Administration and Supervision - Modern Trends, 2nd ed., Al-Farazdaq Commercial Press, Riyadh
Jawdat Ezzat Atwi (2004 AD): Modern School Administration - its theoretical concepts and practical applications, Dar Al-Thaqafa for Publishing and Distribution, Amman, Jordan.
Ibrahim Yassin Al-Khatib, Amal Ibrahim Al-Khatib (2002): Educational Supervision, Dar Qandil, Amman, Jordan
Fahd Ibrahim Al-Habib (1996): Educational Guidance and Supervision in the Arab Gulf States - a study towards preparing a guide for educational guidance and supervision in the Arab Gulf States, the Arab Bureau of Education for the Gulf States, Riyadh.
Muhammad Zain Saleh Al-Saadi (2017 AD): The Effectiveness of Administrative Communication Methods among the Principals of Public Education Schools in the Secretariat of the Capital, Sana'a, from the viewpoint of teachers, International Specialized Educational Journal, No. (10), Volume (6)
Munem Abdel-Qader Othman (2005 AD): Educational Goals of School Administration, Journal of Arts, No. 68, Faculty of Arts, University of Baghdad.
Ziyana Hammoud Khalfan et al (2018): Activating the Joint Supervisory Work among the Educational Supervisor and School Administration in the Sultanate of Oman, Journal of Education, No. (178), Part (1), Faculty of Education, Al-Azhar University
Abdel Khaleq Hanash Saeed et al. (2012 AD): The reality of leadership practice by educational supervisors to overcome resistance to educational change in public education schools in Al-Baha Region, Journal of Reading and Knowledge, Issue (130), Egyptian Association for Reading and Knowledge, Faculty of Education, Ain Shams University
Shafiqa Dawood (2019): The importance of organizing School Time in Primary Education, Journal of Humanities and Social Sciences, No. (54), Center for Generation of Scientific Research, Algeria
The National Center for Educational Research and Development (2008): Total Quality and Education Development, National Bulletin of the National Center for Educational Research and Development, No. 12, Cairo, October
Ibrahim Mubarak Al-Dossary (2000): The framework for educational evaluation, Arab Education Books for the Gulf States, Riyadh
Omar Abdel-Rahim Nasrallah (2010): Principles of Educational and Human Communication, Wael House for Printing, Publishing and Distribution, Amman, Jordan.
Mahmoud Hassan Ismail (2003): Principles of Communication Science and Theories of Influence, International Publishing and Distribution House, Egypt
Tayseer El-Masharqa (2013 AD): Principles in Communication, Osama House for Publishing and Distribution, Amman / Jordan, 1st Edition
Hassan Emad Makkawi , Laila Hassan El-Sayed (1998): Communication and Contemporary Theories, Lebanese-Egyptian House, Egypt
Ali Ahmad Ayasrah , Muhammad Al-Awda (1426 AH): Administrative Communication and Methods of Administrative Leadership in Educational Institutions, Dar Al-Hamed, Amman
Maryam Muhammad Farhan Al-Mishaal (2019): Educational supervision between reality obstacles and solutions for hope, Arab studies in education and psychology, No. (116), Arab Education Association
Ashour Alouti (2014): Obstacles of Achieving Effectiveness in Organizational Communication Tools for Institutions, Journal of Humanities, No. (41), Mentouri University of Constantine
Muhammad Amin Odeh (1997): Obstacles of Administrative Communication in Organizations: An Applied Study on Kuwait University, Journal of Gulf and Arabian Peninsula Studies, No. (84), Year (22), Scientific Publishing Council, Kuwait University.
Hamdi Abul Fotouh Atefa (2002): Scientific Research Methodology and its applications in Educational and Psychological Studies, Cairo, University Publishing House
Chiu, I- Hsuan (2014). Understanding The Relationship of Supervisory Communication, Leader-member Exchange, and Organizational Citizenship Behavior: a united States-Taiwan Comparison. Doctor of Philosophy, Faculty of the Graduate School of the University at Buffalo, State University of New York, Department of Communication
Delini, M. F. (2003). The Relationship of Supervisory Styles to Satisfaction with Supervision and Self–Efficacy of Masters Level Can Skill Students Dh. D. The University ogdouyh Dakota, December.   
Fezler, B. & Brown. C. (2011). The International Model For School Counseling Programs. Sponsored By Aassa And The U.S. State Department Office Of Overseas Schools.
Friedrich Ebert stiftung FES (2014). Monitoring and Evaluation - practical answers to Essential questions. Dakroub Printing & Publishing, Beirut.
Jensen, Ana-Elena.(1994). Mangement communication style inventory - development and assessment of an instrument to measure management communication styly based on the managerial grid theory, D.A.I ,A55/05, 1142
Johnson, B. and Larry C. (2013). Educational Research: Quantitative, Qualitative, and Mixed Approaches. (5th ed.), USA
Leithwood, Kenneth (2005). Educational Accountability - Issues and Alternatives . Saskatchewan School Boards Association , Research Report , May.
Wanzare, Zachariah. O. (2013). Skills and Attributes of Instruction al supervisors - Experience from Kenya. Educational Research and Reviews, 8 (24), 2270-2280.